Lifo and Fifo Article

Lifo and Fifo

LIFO VERSUS FIFO: UPDATING WHAT WE HAVE LEARNED

Nicole Thorne Jenkins Doctoral Scholar in Accounting Morton Mark Associate Mentor of Accounting

College of Business Supervision The University of New jersey 108 PBAB Iowa Metropolis, IA 52242-1000 U. S i9000. A. 319/335-0915 FAX 319/335-1956 [email protected] edu

September 98 (version 1 . 2)

LIFO VERSUS FIFO: UPDATING WHAT WE SHOULD HAVE LEARNED

1 . 0 INTRO The lawful mandate in U. S. tax law that firms using the last-in first-out (LIFO) inventory priced at method for taxes purposes must also use LIFO for monetary reporting uses makes inventory accounting an especially interesting research and teaching topic. The constraint upon managerial acumen imposed by simply tax--book conformity highlights the tension that can exist between taxes minimization, on the one hand, and achieving monetary reporting targets, on the other hand. Trade-offs between taxes minimization and other objectives certainly are a major motif in the Scholes and Wolfson [1992] framework for evaluating taxation inside the context of business strategy. Moreover, a researcher typically can quantify the cash stream impact a good derives by utilizing (or forgoes by not using) LIFO or FIFO, whereas quantifying the cash stream effects of different financial accounting choices is more problematic. you This is because the money flow effects of other accounting choices commonly are indirect (e. g., through contracting costs). It thus can be not surprising that research in the LIFO/FIFO location has a lengthy history. Two reviews of LIFO research have recently been published in the Journal of Accounting Literature. The first appeared inside the initial concern of the Diary and examined LIFO-related exploration as part of a more general overview of capital market assessments of different accounting strategies [Ricks, 1982a]. The second review, posted just 6 year later on, focused entirely on LIFO. It selected three main research fields: the effect of LIFO adoptions on protection prices; the determinants of the inventory accounting choice; as well as the appropriateness of capital industry participants' understanding of LIFO- and FIFO-based earnings [Lindahl, Emby, and Ashton, 1988]. a couple of Notwithstanding the top number of LIFO studies, a mixed (albeit rich) group of results brands much of the analysis into queries such as the effects of LIFO adoption about stock prices and the effect of LIFO and FIFO upon reported earnings and company valuation. While editor of The Accounting Assessment, Abdel-khalik released a " Forum about LIFO Choice of Inventory

1 Since the early on 1970s the S. At the. C. features required organizations using LIFO to as well disclose the excess of current cost above the carrying worth of their LIFO inventory. The AICPA's AuSEC (1984) features recommended disclosure of the " LIFO Reserve” for companies subject to H. E. C. regulations considering that the mid-1980s. two Previous reviews of LIFO/FIFO research also include portions of Lev and Ohlson [1982], in market-based research, and Gonedes and Dopuch [1974], on option means of evaluating the effects or desirability of accounting methods, including capital market research and behavioral clinical experiments. A current paper simply by Thibodeau-Morin and Patton [1998] surveys the entire body of LIFO/FIFO study to identify significant research concerns and methodological approaches. In comparison, we provide an update of the books by detail, analyzing, and synthesizing major research advancements occurring seeing that Lindahl et al. [1988]. Our review which of Thibodeau-Morin and Patton were created independently.

one particular

Valuation” simply by expressing a generally felt frustration regarding research inside the area. He said experts " keep on being relatively uninformed about” several LIFO-related concerns " and know very little about the actual reasons that lots of firms will not switch to LIFO when it appears that they will benefit by positive tax savings” [1992, 319]. He was mentioning the " LIFO dilemna, ” which continues to be invoked in some doing work papers and textbooks....